Your A/F is off, you removed the cats and added 3" exhaust.
Of the 700+ packages we have sent out and the 20+ we have dynoed in house I have never seen a 10.6 A/F with a stage 1 or 2.
Was the reading taken from the tail pipe?
Was the A/F gauge on the dyno clean and running right?
Many factors come into play.
Stock dyno runs are very important as well.
I have seen 2 GT500 dyno under 400RWHP stock.
550-560 is way out of reach for a stage 2. At least SAE corrected numbers. The only guys getting those numbers are posting uncorrected numbers.
Corrected pulley cars are in the 525-535 range all day.
So at 503 your only off by 20-25 RWHP. That could be many things , like engine temp, shop temp, size of the fan used and does this dyno read lower then others.
All dynos are not the same and will not give the same reading for the same mods.
I've had JLT intake and tune cars leave at 487 RWHP to as high as 523 RWHP all using the same exact tune and JLT.
Your boost is at 12.2. This also says you may have had a lower HP car in stock form. The 2.6 will net you 3.5-4 PSI of boost everytime. It will not put you at 13.5-14 PSI, like many are getting, but it will add the 3.5-4 PSI to what you started with.
So if your car was only 8-8.5 stock, you gained 3.5-4 PSI to be at 12.5.
Some problems with the internet is people see what the majority or average are getting and expect it to happen everytime, not everyone is posting corrected numbers because uncorrected looks better, and not all dynos read the same in every part of the world.
To say
"I didn't have any luck! They just made excuses why I dyno'd 503rwhp & 489 rwtq with a stage II" Isn't very fair.
Also, after this dyno you added 3" exhaust, removed the cats and race mufflers and expected Evo to "give" you a new tune because your A/F is in the 10.'s? I don't think that's standerd procedure for any tuner. If you remove the cats and or effect air flow in or out of the engine your tune will be effected and needs to be adjusted. So at 530 with your mods your about right. Get that A/F into the mid 11's and you'll gain even more.
Also note you should have full adjustability in your X-3 to remove fuel in 2% increments. So you really don't need Evo at all.
I'm not defendingEvo here, but trying to give some info that may help give a better understanding on why some reading are lower then others.
Thanks
Jay